Neighbors Cut Fence to Steal Pool After Driveway Dispute

Neighbors Cut Fence to Steal Pool After Driveway Dispute

His neighbors kept parking in his driveway after he installed a gate, they cut through his fence to use his pool
A Removable Fence Panel Gave the Neighbors Access to His Pool

A resident purchased a property that had sat empty for between six and eight months. During this vacancy period, adjacent neighbors utilized the driveway for parking, a practice permitted by the prior owners. When the new owner requested they cease this usage, they persisted, even after he installed a gate specifically designed to block their vehicles.

The conflict escalated significantly after the homeowner took possession. One evening, after dining out with his daughter, he returned home to discover the neighbors swimming in his backyard pool. They had sliced through a section of his privacy fence to remove a panel, allowing them to enter the yard without using the designated gate.

Pre-existing Driveway Usage

According to a post on r/pettyrevenge, user u/rodeopete3281 described how contractors were working on his new home prior to his move-in date. One morning, his contractor alerted him to cars obstructing the driveway.

Upon confronting the neighbors, he learned that the previous owners had granted them permission to park there. The homeowner agreed to allow this arrangement to continue for a few weeks, on the condition that the vehicles were moved by 6 a.m. daily.

Several days later, he arrived to find four cars occupying the space. Following another incident, he summoned two tow trucks. The neighbors emerged from their home before their vehicles were removed but were forced to pay over $300 to retrieve them.

Subsequently, he hired a contractor to install a driveway gate. The neighbors continued to park in the driveway until the installation was finished.

Removable Fence Panel Grants Pool Access

The following Saturday, the homeowner spotted a towel and a child’s flotation device next to his swimming pool. He assumed he had simply forgotten them during a previous visit and discarded them.

That evening, he and his daughter returned from dinner at approximately 9:30 p.m. to find the neighbors enjoying the pool and using the outdoor furniture.

When he confronted them, the children ran toward a corner of the privacy fence and passed through an opening.

For an indefinite period, the neighbors have enjoyed unrestricted access to the pool, a privilege made possible because they removed a section of the privacy fence to facilitate its removal.

The homeowner contacted the police. Based on his account, the neighboring father was arrested for trespassing, property damage, and an outstanding warrant. The adult son was also arrested for an outstanding warrant.

The compromised fence introduced a safety hazard. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention advises four-sided fencing around residential pools, equipped with self-closing and self-latching gates, to help prevent unsupervised child access to the water.

Fence Damage Results in Court Judgment

The homeowner replaced the damaged privacy fence and filed a lawsuit in small-claims court. He reported receiving a $3,800 judgment, which covered 83 feet of eight-foot-high fencing, despite the neighbors damaging only one section.

At the time he shared the story, the money had not yet been paid.

In an update, the homeowner stated he installed six security cameras, a video doorbell, and a separate fence around the swimming pool. He also noted that the neighboring tenants were moving out following a dispute with their landlord regarding unpaid rent.

Reddit users questioned how the neighbors could continue using the property after being instructed to stop. User u/CoderJoe1 expressed concern about potential injuries in the pool.

Another commenter, u/LiquorandLiterature, asked if the homeowner’s actions qualified as petty revenge. The homeowner clarified that the petty aspect was having them towed the last time, just for shits and giggles.

The homeowner later confirmed that while the previous owners allowed driveway parking, they did not authorize the neighbors to use the pool.

Parking issues have sparked other neighborhood conflicts. In another case reported by Homedit, a family removed its shade tree and then began parking under the remaining tree outside the house next door when summer arrived.

Story credit: Reddit user u/rodeopete3281, who shared the experience in r/pettyrevenge.

Source: Homedit.

Related Posts

2 thoughts on “Neighbors Cut Fence to Steal Pool After Driveway Dispute”

  1. Maria Garcia says:

    This is fascinating! Did the neighbors claim a prescriptive easement for the driveway? I’m curious if the fence cutting was legally considered trespassing or just petty retaliation. How did the local zoning laws factor into this?

    • Darcie George says:

      Great questions! While prescriptive easements were debated, the court ultimately ruled the fence cutting was illegal trespass, not valid retaliation. Local zoning didn’t dictate the outcome; property lines did. The neighbors’ action was deemed a self-help remedy gone wrong, costing them dearly in legal fees.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *