
The removal of two large spruce trees from a property boundary cost a homeowner approximately $8,000. The operation required cranes and lasted several days because the trees were situated near buildings. The neighboring landlord declined to pay his portion of the invoice. Later, when the landlord attempted to sell his rental property, a different tree issue compelled him to seek permission from that same homeowner to cross the yard.
The $4,000 Dispute
In a discussion on Reddit's r/pettyrevenge, user u/TheToiletDestroyer stated that roots from the two spruces were damaging his property. He noted that local regulations required both property owners to share the cost of removal.
When asked to contribute $4,000, the landlord responded, "I have no money."
Because hiring an attorney to recover the funds would have incurred additional legal fees without ensuring repayment, the homeowner paid the full amount.
Disputes over trees on property lines are governed by local laws. The Oregon State University Extension notes that trees straddling a boundary may be jointly owned, though liability for removal and costs differs by jurisdiction. The Reddit author did not specify where he lived.
A Home Inspection Created Another Tree Problem
Following the death of his tenant, the landlord decided to sell the rental home. During the inspection, additional trees on his property were flagged as hazardous. According to the Reddit post, the house could not be insured until these hazards were eliminated.
Heavy machinery required access to the trees, but the small lot sizes left the contractor with two choices: cross the neighboring homeowner’s yard or demolish a neighbor’s garage.
The landlord approached the homeowner for permission.
The Neighbor Charged Him $4,000 to Cross the Yard
Rather than denying access, the homeowner demanded the same sum the landlord had refused to pay for the initial tree removal.
The landlord contended that the fee could jeopardize the sale. The homeowner stood firm on the price.
A week later, the landlord returned with a $4,000 check and obtained written permission to use the yard. In a follow-up comment on Reddit, the homeowner confirmed that the check had cleared.
Several commenters believed the homeowner should have charged more. One suggested $5,000 to cover the original expense and the inconvenience, while another proposed $6,000.
Would you have accepted the $4,000 or charged the landlord more to bring heavy equipment across your property?
The post He refused to split an $8,000 tree removal bill: when he tried to sell his house, his neighbor had one condition appeared first on Homedit.

Ah, the classic landlord maneuver: “I’m broke” when it costs money, but suddenly the fence is your personal driveway. Enjoy your premium yard access fee, you magnificent hypocrite.
Spot on! It is always fascinating how costs become personal while access turns into a privilege. Hopefully, the neighbor realizes that shared spaces shouldn’t come with a premium price tag. Thanks for sharing that perspective—it really captures the irony of the situation perfectly.